This week Eugene Healey, who writes about culture and brands, put it in five words: "It's time to de-optimise." His argument is that the backlash against the optimised face, the optimised body and the optimised life is not hedonism. It is people noticing that the promise behind all that optimising was never kept.
I read it on the same day I was reading about restaurants, and the two stories would not stay apart.
Because in my trade, the optimising has never been faster. A restaurant AI cut lunch hours by nearly 20% at one place, and servers' hourly pay went up. Yelp is building an agent that will phone the host stand for a guest and text back the wait. Toast's own survey says restaurant workers are open to AI writing their schedules. Every week the back of house gets a little more efficient.
And the guest, meanwhile, is walking through the front door to get away from exactly that.
What the guest is actually buying
Nobody books a long dinner to save time. They book it to spend time, on purpose, somewhere nobody is measuring them.
That is the quiet contract of a dining room. The kitchen can run like a machine. The floor cannot look like one. Optimise everything the guest can't see. Protect everything they can.
So the interesting question is not whether AI belongs in restaurants. It does, and I build it. The question is where the line sits. What, in a dining room, should never be made efficient, even if it could be?
My answer is a small one. The moment someone hands you the list.
The list, handed to you
A guest wants to be handed a menu and a wine list. Not pointed to a code on the table. Not offered a summary. Handed the thing itself, by a person, with a little weight to it.
And then comes the part I have never been able to make efficient, for anyone, including myself: the scan.
You open the list and your eyes start moving. Regions you know, regions you don't, a page of producers you have always meant to try, a price that makes you blink, a price that makes you curious. It is a little nerve-racking. It is meant to be. That small pressure is the feeling of a real choice, and a real choice is one of the few things left that nobody else can make for you without taking something away.
I have spent my working life on the other side of that list, and the scan still gets me.
A list you have to lift
I went many times to La Tour d'Argent in Paris, one of the great wine programs in the world, and especially deep in Burgundy. The list runs to several hundred pages. The cellar has been reported at around 300,000 bottles.
As a sommelier, that list felt like a candy store fuelled with dopamine. It was also intimidating, even for a wine professional. It is so large and so heavy that it could take hours to scan, page after page of old vintages, vertical after vertical, across grand cru after grand cru.
Every visit was unforgettable, and none of it was efficient. That was the point. It is the beauty of an inefficient European culture: the idea that the choosing is part of the meal, and that a restaurant can make you sit with a book for twenty minutes and call it hospitality.
A recommendation engine could have read me the three best Burgundies for my budget in two seconds. It would have been right, probably. It would also have taken the evening away.
Where efficiency leaks onto the floor
You can tell when the optimising has leaked from the back of house onto the floor. It shows up in the hands.
A rushed pour is the first sign. The glass is filled because the next table is waiting, not because this one is ready.
Worse is a rushed decant. Decanting is one of the few rituals in a dining room that exists only to slow things down. The bottle is opened, the wine is moved with care, the sediment stays where it is, and the table watches something being done properly for them. Rush it and you don't just risk the wine. You tell the table, out loud, that their evening is on someone's clock.
The guest notices. Not in words, and rarely in a review. They notice the way you notice a host glancing at the door while you're still talking.
What AI is for, then
None of this is an argument against the machines. I would happily let software count the inventory, forecast the covers, write the first draft of the schedule and catch the wine on the list that doesn't exist. That is the back of house, and it should be as efficient as we can make it.
But the reason to make the back of house efficient is to buy time for the front. Every minute saved in the office should be a minute given back at the table: the slower pour, the unhurried decant, the twenty minutes with the list.
If the efficiency comes out the other side, onto the floor, we have optimised the one thing the guest came to escape.
Healey is right that people are tired of optimising their lives. The good news for my trade is that we were never supposed to be selling efficiency. We were selling the opposite. Hand them the list, and let them take their time.