I have not eaten at Humm. That goes in the first line because everything below depends on you knowing it.

The short read.

Order: Brigitte's roast chicken, the duck au poivre, the eggplant milanese, the king crab tagliatelle, the milk and honey sundae.

Skip: the caviar bagel, unless you came for the photo.

Book: the dining room. The bar and lounge are a different restaurant, five weeks in.

Open: Tissot Les Graviers Chardonnay with the chicken.

Humm opened on 10 October in the West Village, in the corner room that was En Japanese Brasserie for twenty years. It's the first restaurant in America with Daniel Humm's name on the door: the à la carte little sibling of Eleven Madison Park, built around a wood-fired oven, under a ceiling Francesco Clemente spent two months painting. Tables drop on Resy three weeks out, at noon, and they go.

On the review page most people check first, it has 29 ratings. Twenty-two are five stars. Three are one star. Seven people left a rating and didn't write a word. The booking app says 4.7, another review site 4.3. Three averages, one restaurant, and not one of them will tell you to skip the bagel.

That's the shape of every review page on earth. People write when they're delighted or furious, rarely in between, so the average tells you about mood and nothing about dinner.

So I did what a general manager does with a week of comment cards. I read all of it: the critics, the opening reports, about thirty diners on the public review sites who wrote something real, and every YouTube video I could find. I used AI to pull and sort every review; the counting rules and the calls are mine. I stopped asking whether each one liked the place. I asked what they ate, where they sat, and where people who have never met said the same thing about the same plate.

One critic is one night. Seven strangers agreeing about a dish is a kitchen.

So instead of stars, every dish below gets a count: how many independent eaters were for it, how many against.

Who's in the stack

Not every voice weighs the same, and the first job is sorting them.

The Infatuation sent its New York editor. Robert Sietsema ate most of the menu for his own newsletter and wrote down every price, which I trust more than adjectives. Elite Traveler liked everything it touched; it doesn't say whether the meal was hosted, so it never carries a dish alone. A diner blogger booked the lounge, paid around $300 and left furious. A lifestyle newsletter named three must-orders and nothing else.

And the restaurant itself, which is the source most reviewers skip. Humm publishes its sample menus and its whole wine list, 97 pages, dated 12 November. Every price below comes from there unless a reviewer paid something different.

Then the crowd. Public reviews are noisy, but they have one thing the critics don't: volume. Ten diners who logged a price all put Humm at over $100 a head. Several scored dish by dish, out of five. One had eaten in both the bar and the dining room, which turns out to matter more than anything else here.

And one YouTube review: a small Korean food channel that filmed a dinner of a dozen plates, showed the bill, and liked almost everything. A source that loves everything still counts, but I read it the way I'd read a regular's comment card. Their one complaint is worth more than their ten compliments.

Then six Shorts, the minute-long vertical videos. I treat them like a hosted meal: they count, but none carries a dish alone, because nobody builds a following by filming sixty seconds of disappointment. Reading them properly took the transcript, not the thumbnail. One thumbnail says the chicken is stuffed with foie gras and black truffles. The video itself says that was Humm's old chicken, from a restaurant that closed five years ago. The new one is brioche and parmesan. Anyone who skimmed the thumbnails now believes something false about the most expensive dish on the menu.

And this is the part no star average will ever do for you. One Short and one written review posted the same day, named the same three must-order dishes in the same order, and are almost certainly the same person. One Short credits a dining companion whose first name matches a reviewer who praised the same four dishes. On a star average, those are four votes. Here they're two.

No Times review yet. I couldn't find an Eater review either.

Order these

Brigitte's roast chicken for two, $108. For 9, against 1. Named for Humm's mother, with brioche and parmesan under the skin. Only one critic ate it. Eight more eaters backed them up. One, who swore they'd never normally pay three figures for a chicken, said it was worth it. Two who remember the famous NoMad chicken held this one up against it, and one said it's better. One diner said skip it. Nine to one is about as loud as a five-week-old restaurant gets.

Duck au poivre, $68. For 7, against 0. Sietsema's dish of the night, medium, green peppercorn, prunes. Six more voices agree and nobody dissents. The Korean food channel's only complaint about its entire dinner was that the duck came out more cooked than they'd like. If you want it pink, say so when you order.

Eggplant milanese, $30. For 12, against 1. And here is the reason to curate rather than pick a critic.

Sietsema found it too sweet, like takeout sweet and sour. Twelve other people disagreed with him. Two called it one of their favourite dishes of the year. The same channel called it the best plate of a twelve-plate dinner and compared the crust to Korean fried chicken, which from them is not faint praise. Read only Sietsema and you'd have skipped the dish the room loves most.

Milk and honey sundae, $18. For 9, against 2. Same story. Sietsema called it ordinary vanilla. Nine people loved it, one calling it among the best ice cream desserts they'd ever had. Not one critic praised it. The crowd won.

The pickles, $12. For 6, against 0. Two people who came for the famous dishes named it among their favourites of the night. Vegetables from Humm's own farm upstate. A $12 plate is where a kitchen shows you whether it's serious when nobody is photographing anything.

Apple tart. For 5, against 0. One wished it came out warmer.

Anything from the raw bar. For 8, against 1. The tuna and hamachi crudo ($38) is the most consistent pick. The scallop with yuzu and pistachio has two fans and one who found it too sweet, at $18 for two pieces.

King crab tagliatelle, $48. For 7, against 1. Sietsema called it spectacular. One diner with a camera called it the most perfectly cooked pasta of their life. The blogger said it went pasty and the crab was hard to find. Seven to one says order it. The one dissent says eat it the second it lands.

Coin flips

Rigatoni pomodoro, $28. For 2, against 1. Perfectly al dente for two diners, mushy in places and raw in others for a third.

When one plate gets "perfect" and "raw" in the same month, the recipe is fine and the line isn't consistent yet. Pasta is the first thing to suffer on a slammed pass, and two of the three pastas here have a dissent that reads like timing, not taste.

Roasted lobster with tarragon, $88. For 1, against 0. One vote, but a detailed one: perfectly cooked, and cleaned more carefully than its one reviewer had seen anywhere, down to the small joints. Not enough to call. Enough to ask your server about.

Crispy feta, $16. For 3, against 3. The most divisive plate on the menu. Delicious and too small for some, flavourless and not even crispy for others, including Sietsema. At $16, find out yourself.

Baked sweet potatoes, $28. For 0, against 1. The only dish on the menu with nothing but a dissent.

The bagel

The caviar bagel, $34. For 4, against 4.

It appears in all six Shorts. Two of the six say it tastes good.

Everyone agrees on one thing, and it isn't flavour. Sietsema, The Infatuation and three people who filmed it all mention the size first: bite-sized, smaller than it looked on Instagram. A diner who knows Humm's other rooms said the bread outweighed the caviar. One advised ordering several. Another said they could live without it. The four who loved it loved it as a bite, not as a value.

So the most famous dish at Humm splits evenly on taste and wins unanimously on camera. Humm's own booking page asks guests to go easy on flash photography. The bagel didn't get the memo.

That's not a dish. That's a marketing budget with a plate under it. Order one for the table if you want the photo. Spend the next $34 on the pickles and the crudo.

Two restaurants under one roof

This is the finding I'd charge for.

Every detailed review of the main dining room is warm. Good service, good pacing, a room quiet enough to whisper across the table, which in New York is a minor miracle.

Now look where the complaints come from. A walk-in who asked for the bar at six, was told two hours and forty-five minutes, came back on time, and was told there'd be no seat that night. A party in the lounge who said the drinks took forever and the staff couldn't decide whether they were running a bar or a dining room. A couple at a bar table in a side section who felt like the undesirable guests. A party in a side room with couches who said it felt like a coffee shop and nobody came by. The blogger, refused a move from lounge to bar and given 45 minutes on two stools.

Six detailed service complaints. Five came from the bar, the lounge, a side room or the walk-in list. The sixth doesn't say where they sat, only that the drinks took 45 minutes and arrived with the mains.

That isn't a rude staff. It's a structure. The dining room is the restaurant Humm built. The overflow rooms run on a different, shorter menu, a policy their guests don't understand, and a bar that seems to be pouring for everyone at once. When two separate tables say the drinks were that late, I stop blaming the server and start looking at who else the service bar is pouring for.

I've watched this from the inside. I was the opening sommelier at a hotel restaurant on the coast that the whole city had been waiting for. It had a dining room and a lounge. The dining room ran on pure voltage: the private room full of VIP bookings, chefs and managers watching every plate and every table. The lounge got attention too. Just less of it.

Nobody decided that. Nobody had to. In an opening, attention goes where the pressure is, and the pressure is always in the main room.

That's what I think these reviews are describing at Humm. Not a bad bar. A second room living on the leftovers of everyone's attention.

The practical advice: book the dining room. A bar or lounge reservation is a different menu and, five weeks in, a different restaurant. Don't plan your night around the walk-in list.

And "hardest reservation in New York" needs a footnote. Resy shows Humm holds tables for American Express's Global Dining Access cardholders, which is part of why the public calendar looks full. On the Wednesday I checked, dining-room tables were open the same night at 10 and 10:30. Hard to get at eight. Not hard to get.

The part nobody reviewed

No critic assessed the wine. Four diners did. Three managed a line each: a superbly curated list, a sommelier whose picks were spot on.

The one long video review named the bottles, which nobody else bothered to do. Gaston Chiquet's Special Club 2004, an aged grower Champagne, still fresh. Then a light California red by the glass, chosen by the sommelier for the duck. And when they asked for Chartreuse that wasn't on the menu, it came anyway.

So I read the list myself. Humm publishes it: 97 pages, dated 12 November, about 1,490 bottles.

Start at the bottom, because that's where a list tells you who it's for. The cheapest glass is $18: a Romorantin from Cour-Cheverny, the only varietal that appellation allows, and an obscure, high-acid one most guests have never heard of. Eighteen dollars is not expensive for a glass in New York, and in a room at Humm's level it's close to generous. The opening pour at a room like this is usually the safe bottle nobody will question. Duffy, the wine director, who came from Italian lists downtown and taught biology before that, chose the one most likely to start a conversation. The same wine is $70 a bottle, four glasses at the glass price, which is the honest way to do it.

The glass list is less French than the coverage suggests: six French, five American, the rest from Spain, Portugal, Austria, Italy and New Zealand. The light California red with the duck was almost certainly the Turley Cinsault from Lodi, at $23 a glass. A $23 glass with a $68 duck is a sommelier pouring for the plate, not the check.

The bottles are another room entirely. The median bottle is $275. One in ten is $100 or under, and the cheapest is a $55 País from Chile. A quarter of the list is Burgundy, about 340 bottles, and the median red Burgundy is $600. At the top sits a 1990 Romanée-Saint-Vivant from the Domaine de la Romanée-Conti at $17,220.

Then the Champagne: 127 bottles, nearly all grower, from $130 for a rosé and $145 for a brut up to five Selosse cuvées at $3,335 each. Krug's Grande Cuvée is $490, which by New York standards is a gentle markup on a famous name. The 2004 Chiquet from that dinner isn't on the list. Either it sold through, or it lives in the cellar rather than on the page.

So the glasses are written for people who drink, and the bottles for people who collect. The reviewers talked about cocktails far more than wine, which may be why nobody noticed there are two lists here.

It's a good list. It covers an enormous amount of ground, and that's my problem with it.

There are 690 producers on it, and more than half appear exactly once. Only 43 wines show up in three vintages or more, and the deepest runs aren't where a room like this should dig: a Languedoc red, Musar, a Provence rosé, a Tuscan, a Napa Cabernet. Burgundy fills a quarter of the list and goes five vintages deep at most. Seven bottles in ten are from 2020 or younger. And the top end is auction-grade wine at auction-house prices.

Wide where I'd want it deep. If it were my list, I'd spend the same pages going deep in three places, Champagne, Burgundy and Piedmont: fewer producers, more vintages of each. A great list teaches you a place. This one proves the cellar has a bit of everything.

So what would I open with the chicken? I'd go to the Jura: André et Mireille Tissot, Les Graviers Chardonnay, from Arbois, 2023, $240. Brown butter, parmesan and a buttered brioche stuffing need acid with real tension. The lemon and thyme under the skin want a wine already thinking along those lines, and a roast jus wants something savoury enough to stand beside it.

It's one of nine Jura whites in 97 pages. The best bottle for the dish everyone orders is hiding in the list's smallest corner.

And one more silence, which turned out to be the reviewers', not the restaurant's. In about fifty reviews and videos, nobody mentions what Humm pours for a guest who isn't drinking. The bar menu answers it: three zero-proof cocktails at $18, three to six dollars under the real ones, built on proper non-alcoholic bases with tea, celery, yuzu and dates. One carries an asterisk saying it contains up to 0.5 percent alcohol.

That asterisk is the most honest line on any of Humm's menus, and it's the line a sober guest needs to see. What's missing is everything after the cocktail. Nothing non-alcoholic appears anywhere in 97 pages of wine, so the guest who isn't drinking gets a good first drink and then a glass of water next to a $108 chicken.

What it costs

Order the way the evidence says: two martinis from the cart at $24, the pickles, the eggplant, the chicken for two, one milk and honey. That's $216 before tax and tip, about $140 a head after both. Before a single bottle.

The only real bill on the record comes from that same video: two people, a dozen plates, lobster, cocktails, a 2004 Champagne and Chartreuse to finish. About $970 before tip. Same menu, other end.

The sharpest comment on price in the whole stack came from Greece. A Greek food creator posted three minutes on Humm to a Greek audience. The most-liked reply, translated, says it's like a decent neighbourhood restaurant in Pagrati, a residential part of Athens. Read the menu and you see what they saw: marinated olives, fava purée, a salad of tomato, cucumber and barrel-aged feta. In Pagrati that salad is a weeknight side. At Humm it's $28.

The read

Two days before opening, a YouTube crew followed Eleven Madison Park's chef de cuisine into Humm's last friends-and-family night and asked Humm the question every review in this stack circles. At his level, why take another risk?

"I love the game," he said. Then, roughly: he loves restaurants, and he can't stop.

In late 2022 he told Haute Living he wanted to focus on one restaurant and had no interest in an empire. Three rooms later, I believe the second answer. It's also the best news in this whole read for the bar and the lounge. A chef who opens a restaurant because he can't stop is the chef who'll still be in it in month three.

A serious dining room, cooking more good things than its critics have noticed, attached to a bar and lounge that aren't ready yet. Go for the chicken, the duck, the eggplant, the crab tagliatelle and the sundae, in the main room. Eat the pasta fast. Leave the bagel to the people photographing it.

That's thirteen published sources, a dozen videos, about forty diners, a 97-page wine list, and one dinner I haven't had.

I'll eat there. I want to; that's the whole point. This was never a substitute for dinner. It's the first half of an experiment: read everything, commit to a call, then sit down and find out what the reading got wrong.

That second half is the project. I'll publish it dish by dish.

The count

Every vote below comes from someone who ate there and said something specific about the dish. Critics and publications count by name; diners count but are never named. Videos count like a possibly hosted meal: they can support a dish, never carry one alone. Prices are from Humm's own menus, 10 October, and wine list, 12 November.

DishPriceForAgainstGrade
Roast chicken for two$10891High
Duck au poivre$6870High
Eggplant milanese$30121High
Milk and honey sundae$1892High
Apple tart50High
Pickles$1260High
Raw bar (crudo, mussels, clams, scallops)$14-3881High
King crab tagliatelle$4871High, consistency flag
Tomato focaccia$972High
Roasted lobster, tarragon$8810Low
Chicory, tangerine, poppy seed$2410Low
Coffee almond granita21Medium, texture flag
Uni toast$4810Low
Truffle flatbread$2621Medium
Chocolate mousse (vegan)21Medium
Rigatoni pomodoro$2821Medium, consistency flag
Crispy feta$1633Split
Caviar bagel$3444Split; filmed in 6 of 6 Shorts
Baked sweet potatoes$2801Low, against
Bar only: fried chicken$2811Split
Bar only: mushroom burger$2511Split
Fries$1431High
Cocktails$21-24 (zero-proof $18)61High
Wine list / sommelier40High (no critic; one diner named bottles)

A dish needs at least three independent eaters for it, and at least three times as many for as against, to grade High. Praise like "everything was delicious" counts for nothing, and "fine" counts as neutral. A split is either consistency (same dish, cooked differently on different nights) or palate (same dish, different tastes), because they mean opposite things.